Verified Document

Suspects Have A Right To Be Silent Term Paper

Miranda v. Arizona In the original case involving Miranda v. Arizona, 22-year-old Ernesto Miranda

stood accused of the rape of an 18-year-old female (and kidnapping and robbery).

The arrest happened on March 18, 1963. Miranda was arrested in his home and taken to a Phoenix police station, where he was interrogated and given a confession to sign -- which he did sign. On that confession, the police had typed in that Miranda fully understood his legal rights even though he was not notified that he had the right to remain silent (by not incriminating himself) and he had the right to legal counsel. Miranda was sentenced to 20 to 30 years in prison. This was an example of a heavy-handed strategy used by Phoenix police against a Latino man who was not fully mentally sound, according to the literature on the case.

Miranda v. Arizona -- the broader implications and the U.S. Supreme Court

Meanwhile, the U.S. Supreme Court heard an appeal from Miranda's attorney -- that his constitutional rights had been abused. And on June 13, 1966, the High Court made an historic ruling that is considered one of the most important decisions regarding justice in the history of the United States. The Court ruled that the 5th Amendment to the...

Hence, in legal situations (not necessarily arrests) a person on the spot can "Take the Fifth," or in other words, can refuse to speak to the issue in fear of self-incrimination (Shay, 2012). Also, the 6th Amendment ensures the right to a fair trial (i.e., due process) which Miranda clearly did not receive.
The Justices voted 5-4 in a ruling that Miranda's confession was "…not admissible evidence in the criminal trial" since the Phoenix police failed to inform him of his rights (Shay, p. 1). Interestingly, the High Court decided to hear three cases along with the Miranda ruling, since the other three cases involved similar circumstances.

In Vignera v. New York, the police in New York City arrested a suspect that was accused of robbing a dress shop. Shortly thereafter he was taken to a police station where he "…orally admitted to the robbery" and was officially placed under arrest (uscourts.gov). In Westover v. United States a suspect was arrested because he was suspected of being involved in a pair of robberies in the Kansas City area. After being interrogated twice by local police, then…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Columbia Electronic Encyclopedia. (2013). Miranda v. Arizona. Retrieved September 28,

2014, from http://www.cc.columbia.edu.

Shay, A. (2012). Tag Archive for 'Vignera v. New York.' Retrieved September 28, 2014,

From http://lcrm.lib.unc.edu.
US Courts. (2010). Facts and Case Summary. Retrieved September 28, 2014, from http://www.uscourts.gov.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Self Incrimination and Right to Counsel Approach
Words: 2485 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

The idea of remaining silent when faced with accusation has historical religious and legal roots. Moses teachings', transformed to written form by the ancient Talmudic law had a complete ban on self-incrimination. The self-incrimination law could not be changed because it was viewed to contravene the natural instinct for survival. The ancient common law rule also had it that confusions must be voluntary. When the right to remain silent was

Criminal Process from Arraignment to Pre Trial
Words: 3011 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Criminal Process; Arraignment to Pre-Trial The purpose of criminal law is to promote respect for the law by people and ensure a just, safe, and peaceful society. The American justice system has many commendable elements that are aligned to the objectives of a justice system. The trial system significantly addresses many point of subtlety and does a great job in its effort to uphold the rule of law. In the effort

Supreme Courts 1966 Miranda Ruling Legalities and Issues
Words: 1211 Length: 4 Document Type: Article Review

Miranda Ruling: Its Past, Present and Future In almost all cases, the Miranda ruling of 1966 applies to police interviews with criminal suspects, although other Supreme Court decisions extend some of the rights to legal counsel and prevention of self-incrimination to public and private employers. According to the Supreme Court, the Miranda Warnings must be given prior to questioning to all persons who have been arrested and are in police

Miranda Vs. Arizona
Words: 1279 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Miranda Issues in Law Enforcement In 1966, the U.S. Supreme Court decided the landmark case of Ernesto Miranda, who had been arrested by Arizona police on suspicion of rape. The suspect confessed to the crime after two hours of questioning by police while in their custody, without ever having been advised of his 5th Amendment right against self-incrimination or his 6th Amendment right to legal representation before such questioning. Ever since the Miranda

Legal Issues in Miranda V.
Words: 1799 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

" (p. 471). Finally, the Court ruled that the police could not interrogate suspects who expressed the desire to exercise their right to remain silent and that. "Once warnings have been given, the subsequent procedure is clear. If the individual indicates in any manner, at any time prior to or during questioning, that he wishes to remain silent, the interrogation must cease." (pp. 473-74). If the interrogation continues and if the

Criminal Law Foundations Evaluation Criminal Law Foundations
Words: 1658 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Criminal Law Foundations Evaluation Criminal Law Foundations Paper Constitution signifies different political contexts safeguarding the well-being of the citizens, as well as, the convicts in the state. The constitution gives an integrated model of a republic that dictates the roles, responsibilities of different arms of the legal and criminal justice system that ensure social equity and coercion. It is recognizable that each state has a unique political system characterized by "checks and

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now